Find a course

The UK Post Office Affair: A Cautionary Tale for Ireland

Government/Public Bodies March 7, 2024

The UK Post Office scandal is a significant and distressing episode that unfolded over several years. The scandal revolves around the Horizon software system, which was used by the British Post Office. Faulty software, provided by Fujitsu and known as Horizon, led to false shortfalls in the accounts of thousands of sub postmasters. These sub postmasters were accused of theft, fraud, and false accounting based on erroneous data from Horizon.

Extent and Impact:

  • Between 1999 and 2015, over 900 sub postmasters faced criminal convictions due to the flawed Horizon data.
  • Approximately 700 of these prosecutions were carried out by the Post Office itself.
  • Other sub postmasters were either prosecuted but not convicted, forced to cover Horizon shortfalls with their own money, or had their contracts terminated.
  • The consequences were severe: court cases, imprisonments, loss of livelihoods, debts, bankruptcies, and even suicides.
  • Families suffered from stress, illness, and breakdowns.

Post Office’s Role:

  • Despite sub postmasters reporting issues with Horizon, the Post Office insisted that the system was robust.
  • They failed to disclose their knowledge of faults in the software while securing convictions.
  • The scandal has been described as one of the most widespread miscarriages of justice in British history.

Legal Battles and Compensation:

  • In 2019, a judge ruled that sub postmasters’ contracts with the Post Office were unfair and that Horizon had bugs, errors, and defects.
  • A group action in the High Court resulted in a £58 million settlement (about £20,000 per claimant after legal costs).
  • The government supplemented these awards.
  • The judge’s rulings paved the way for sub postmasters to challenge their convictions.
  • An independent inquiry into the scandal was established in 2020.

Recent Developments:

  • As of February 2024, 100 sub postmasters’ convictions have been overturned in court.
  • The government announced plans for a blanket exoneration.
  • Wrongfully convicted individuals and those affected by the scandal are now eligible for compensation from the Post Office.

Why should this case matter to solicitors and regulators in Ireland?

The UK Post Office scandal highlights the importance of accountability, transparency, and fairness in financial systems. Solicitors and regulators in Ireland can learn from this case to ensure that similar miscarriages of justice do not occur within their own systems. It underscores the need for rigorous scrutiny of software systems, especially when they impact people’s livelihoods and well-being. By studying this scandal, legal professionals can advocate for better practices, protect vulnerable individuals, and uphold justice.

Join us at the Regulatory Investigations conference on March 21st and 22nd where Mark Heffer, international financial crime expert, will delve into the intricacies of the UK Post Office Horizon IT scandal (this online conference will be held over 2 half days, from 9.30 to 1pm).

Join our mailing list to receive notifications of upcoming courses and events